Thanks for the replies.
I have a directory with two JPGs that I save the same way, both with the Adobe profile I presume from the RAW file (as that is what my camera is set to). I hover over both of the images, one shows AdobeRGB with asterisks around, and the other shows sRGB with asterisks around. I swear, I did the same thing to both files - bit of retouching, crop, flatten, save again at 12 quality for print.
When I check the adobe info, they both are showing AdobeRGB.
Jason