[
Sorry
Looking at some of the files yesterday I'd say they need DFS 10 and 200.
If I put that in the RAW preference and find they are over sharpened I cannot reduce the sharpening in the Edit stage - or can I?
If I can't it would be a real bore to have to create a new RAW preference just for a few files.
I can see the point in stating a preference for noise removal but what is the point in having a DFS preference if you are going to need a further DFS in Edit mode?
Tony
Tony I am going to go over your post line by line,.
1) Fred but I don't understand why Mike wants us to have two DFS settings.
Options holds the Preset sharpening so Raw files do not look like mush. All raw developing programs have a preset sharpening. Forget the DFS name for a moment. It's Preset sharpening.
2) Looking at some of the files yesterday I'd say they need DFS 10 and 200.
If that's what they need, then that's what they need.
You implied earlier that the new camera was producing softer images... all of them!
Then the Preset sharpening would need adjustment.
3) If I put that in the RAW preference and find they are over sharpened I cannot reduce the sharpening in the Edit stage - or can I
Yes you can by inserting a minus in front of the strength in the DFS in the editor.
4)If I can't it would be a real bore to have to create a new RAW preference just for a few files.
This implies that it is only a few files that are in dire need of more sharpening. That implies that the overall images are OK with the standard current Option Preset. Therefore, it is not the camera and all images.
5) I can see the point in stating a preference for noise removal but what is the point in having a DFS preference if you are going to need a further DFS in Edit mode?
Asked and answered, but I'll try again.
The raw images are inherently soft. A sharpening Preset is used to get a decent image on screen.
Some images need more sharpening than others...... Some images call for sharpening a white bird, but no sharpening of a blue sky... There is no one fita all setting. It sounds like you never used Tone Targeted Sharpening.
Last example.... I want you to picture this...
I have a friend with a NIKON D 800... When he raises the iso in that camera on an indoor scene, his images look like they were taken in a sand storm.
In Options, we set the Noise reduction to turn on much sooner than default, and since that softens the image, we improved the PRESET sharpening.
The ISO was 3200 pushed by QU to 10,400 to get a good printable image. The Noise reduction was full on ... both regular and chroma.
I hope this helps.
Fred